How to write a proposal for introducing AI | Cost-effectiveness calculation example and entry template
The approval document for introducing AI indicates the current work burden, the scope of change, the necessary costs, and how to stop it in case of failure, rather than just because it "seems convenient" or "competitor is also using it." Rather than requiring company-wide implementation from the beginning, it will be easier to review if you separate the budget required for small verification and the criteria for making a decision on going live.
Seven items that the approver wants to confirm
| Item | What to write |
|---|---|
| Background | Who is in trouble in which work and to what extent |
| Target | Parts left to AI and parts judged by humans |
| Comparison proposal | Maintaining the status quo, improving procedures, existing tools, introducing AI |
| Cost | Initial cost, monthly fee, usage fee, in-house man-hours |
| Effectiveness | Measurable indicators such as time, quality, processing capacity, etc. |
| Risks | Incorrect answers, authority, obstacles, and data handling |
| Judgment conditions | When, who, and what to look at to decide whether to continue or cancel |
If you also compare "improvement plans that do not use AI," it will be less likely that the approval will be for the purpose of introducing AI itself.
Example of cost-effectiveness calculation including confirmation man-hours
The following is a hypothetical example to show how it is calculated and is not an actual price or ZETTAi track record.
- Target work: Drafting 200 reports every month.
- Conventional: 20 minutes per item. After using AI: 12 minutes per item including confirmation and correction.
- Monthly time reduction: 200 cases x 8 minutes ÷ 60 = approximately 26.7 hours.
- Converted amount of surplus capacity assuming hourly rate is 3,000 yen: 80,000 yen per month.
- Monthly usage/maintenance fee: 30,000 yen. Operation management: 5 hours per month x 3,000 yen = 15,000 yen.
- Monthly deduction effect: 80,000 - 30,000 - 15,000 = 35,000 yen.
- If the initial cost is 300,000 yen, simple payback period: 300,000 ÷ 35,000 = approximately 8.6 months.
The value of free time is not the same as saving cash. Please distinguish between whether overtime and outsourcing costs will actually be reduced or whether time will be allocated to other tasks. Also, if the number of cases per month is 100, the deduction effect is 40,000-45,000 = minus 5,000 yen. Even with the same settings, the judgment changes depending on the number of cases.
Summarize the entry examples on one page
The target is limited to drafting monthly reports. Approval and sending outside the company are done by people. The verification uses available materials, records the time taken from preparation to confirmation, and records any significant errors. The cost limit, implementation period, and person in charge are decided in advance, and if the work load is greater than the conventional method or if the information management conditions are not met, the actual transition will be postponed.
Fill in the actual measurements, person in charge, and schedule in this document, and attach a written estimate. Please use the Entry field on the approval form to distinguish unconfirmed numbers as estimates.
Points that are likely to be stopped during the examination
By showing only the usage fee as an expense, you can eliminate the burden of training, setup, and updating materials. If the effectiveness is expressed only by the maximum value, you will overlook the possibility that it will become unprofitable if the number of uses is small. We will compare normal, small, and large numbers of cases and explain which assumptions can be continued.
We also confirm the contract period, cancellation conditions, data return, and handover of operations personnel. Rather than summarizing the expected benefits into a single number, it is more helpful to indicate conditions and uncertainties in decision making.
FAQ
Do I always need to calculate ROI in monetary terms?
If quality and response speed are the main objectives, indicate these using separate metrics. Rather than forcefully converting effects that cannot be measured into monetary amounts, we clarify what improvements the investment will make to the budget.
Can I request approval even if the effects have not been measured?
We can present cost limits and evaluation methods as verification approval to confirm effectiveness. Don't write unmeasured effects as confirmed results.
Before consulting ZETTAi
Please organize the current working hours, the assumptions for introduction costs, and the period to confirm the effects. Regarding ZETTAi's AI system development/contracted development, we can discuss the requirements and implementation scope required for an estimate. The scope of individual support will be confirmed at the time of consultation.